Not playing time in the sense that recruits were afraid they wouldn’t get any, but in the sense that too much playing time would get them murdered, because that’s what happened to junior forward Patrick Dennehy in the summer of 2003. Dennehy, and friend Carlton Dotson, had become increasingly worried about their safety after transferring to Baylor the year prior. Threats had been coming from the most unlikely place: Baylor squad teammates.
On June 14, Dennehy and Dotson voiced these concerns once again to a mutual friend, and then finished their conversation by mentioning a party they were planning on attending the next day. However, neither man showed up at the party that next night.
A few weeks later Dotson was taken into custody and charged with the murder of Dennehy. A cousin of Dotson’s told local police that he had overheard Dotson bragging about the shooting. On July 30, Dennehy’s body was found; gunshots to the head confirmed the police suspicions of homicide. Five days prior to his trial, Dotson plead guilty to the murder of his friend and teammate, citing playing time as his main motive.
Further investigation uncovered that then head coach Dave Bliss knew about the murder and instructed the rest of the team to lie to investigators about what had happened. He had been recorded as telling his team to tell investigators that Dennehy was a drug dealer on campus and that the shooting was an unfortunate consequence of a deal gone south. Bliss immediately resigned from his position after this was revealed, but received no criminal punishment.
In the immediate aftermath of this incident, the NCAA threatened not just to suspend the Baylor basketball program, but to scrap it all together. The NCAA found that extreme of a measure unnecessary but did impose sanctions due to the schools recently revealing of substance abuse and tuition violations concerning student-athletes.
Since this incident, many people had brushed Baylor under the rug, assuming they would never be heard from again. However, new head coach Scott Drew was not about to let that happen. Drew, a former college coach at Valparaiso, took the job with the intention of bringing Baylor basketball back. As seen in this year’s NCAA Tournament, Drew has accomplished that goal.
Since the murder seven years ago, Baylor has struggled in the area of performance, but the simple fact that they are performing is a feat in itself. They had every reason to drop their program and rid themselves of a potentially crippling stigma that would forever loom over them, but they chose not to fold. Drew, along with dedicated young men he has recruited, have brought Baylor back from the lowest of lows. They were not the normal definition of a Cinderella team, and even though they lost in the Elite Eight to the top seeded Duke, the Baylor Bears are sitting on campus right now in Texas, rightly holding their heads high. They know the amazing things they have overcome and accomplished, and for that, we should all be cheering for them still. Congratulations on the greatest comeback of all time Baylor. Go Bears!